Deleted member 12493
Guest
- Thread starter
- #1
Can’t sleep at night? Check out my latest video; So much to cover… We did our best, but are open to any pro-tips from all of you!
Sponsored
The fact that the car’s dependency on internet in order to do quick route planning is a downside of the decision to calculate routes in the cloud away from the cars personal compute power How do you feel about this decision? My two cents is that I am surprised at the time difference between local calc and cloud based calc. But as long as you don’t lose actual functionality, it’s a good trade off. The cloud based calculations are super quick Maybe Porsche can somehow local calculations done in the car thoughThat quick routeplanning demo near the end that didn't go quick was because of lack of internet connectivity. It's shown by that little globe on the map, lower left hand corner above the plus sign with a line through it.
How do I know this? I have been without internet connectivity for a month now...
It seems to me that in addition to speed, the other reason to do the cloud-based planning is theoretically you would have up-to-the-moment charge station info as the route is being planned. At least I would hope so.The fact that the car’s dependency on internet in order to do quick route planning is a downside of the decision to calculate routes in the cloud away from the cars personal compute power How do you feel about this decision? My two cents is that I am surprised at the time difference between local calc and cloud based calc. But as long as you don’t lose actual functionality, it’s a good trade off. The cloud based calculations are super quick Maybe Porsche can somehow local calculations done in the car though
Great point Huge fan of cloud based sevices ie Waze etc for this very reason. Thanks for adding this context for this application hadn’t consideredIt seems to me that in addition to speed, the other reason to do the cloud-based planning is theoretically you would have up-to-the-moment charge station info as the route is being planned. At least I would hope so.
I think the approach to route planning in this car is impressively flexible, in that it lets you use CarPlay also, and that Apple maps is as well integrated into the system as it is (showing up on both screens and HUD.) I would like to see Google Maps as well integrated (I am guessing that it would be on Android Auto). Now that Google Maps shows road hazard info also, there's much less reason to use Waze. The downside is that the Porsche route planner is not great for local route planning, and it has a tendency to choose some bizarre routes at times.Great point Huge fan of cloud based sevices ie Waze etc for this very reason. Thanks for adding this context for this application hadn’t considered
True, the info could be sent to the car and calculations still be done on board. This would be true with both traffic and charge station info. But the charge station/range optimizations, (on top of traffic, I suppose), is probably a big load to carry on a long route for the car's computer.If they are considering real time busy/down chargers and traffic in the route planing, then that data needs to get to the planning software and then to the display. Doing the calculation in the cloud and sending results vs sending data and calculating locally should not make any difference except for the calculation speed.
Spotty or slow cell service (internet access) is a problem for any of these apps that use real time data. I wonder if the Macan stores all the area maps like conventional GPS routing, or is it downloading maps as it goes like typical cell phone apps.... (unless manually downloaded).
Did you pass through areas of spotty cell coverage during your cross country trip and did you notice the impact on the navigation. I presume charging stations would have decent cell coverage.
I think it's probably more efficient to have it done in the cloud at a single point so you don't have gazillions of Macans asking for traffic conditions and charge station occupancy figures. And let's not forget the excellent opportunity for vendor lockin here...The fact that the car’s dependency on internet in order to do quick route planning is a downside of the decision to calculate routes in the cloud away from the cars personal compute power How do you feel about this decision? My two cents is that I am surprised at the time difference between local calc and cloud based calc. But as long as you don’t lose actual functionality, it’s a good trade off. The cloud based calculations are super quick Maybe Porsche can somehow local calculations done in the car though